international analysis and commentary

An American view of Europe’s “Strategic Autonomy”: a win for China?

24

Europe’s self-proclaimed middle powers are attempting to assert their independence on the international stage by banding together. In Emmanuel Macron’s recent swing through Asia, the French President called for a “coalition of independents” made up of middle powers to reduce dependency on the hegemons. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz is encouraging Europeans to adopt a “middle power mindset” to avoid becoming victims of great power rivalry. Finnish President Alexander Stubb, for his part, has urged European nations to align with the “Global Middle,” arguing that the continent’s relevance depends on building a powerful bloc of non-superpower democracies.

The assertion of independent middle power status is partly a reaction to US recognition that the rules-based international order does not supplant the national interest, and that it is more American hard power than unenforceable appeals to global institutions and liberal democracy that provides security and keeps the sea lanes open and the autocrats at bay. The results of the midterm elections are unlikely to change this fundamental shift in US policy. As Secretary Rubio asserted in Greece, the US is now in “unapologetic pursuit of national power,” and the executive branch will continue to prioritize efforts to “take back control of our critical supply chains, to reindustrialize our economy, to rebuild our defense, to fight for dominance of the technologies and industries of the future.”

 

The pursuit of national power is not, as some have argued, to reject the post-WWII formula that paired democratic ideals with robust alliances and American hard power (the very approach that rebuilt Europe, contained Soviet expansion, and created the conditions for the prosperity the middle powers still enjoy). Instead, it is a rejection of the post-Cold War delusion and strategic narcissism that gave way to the mistaken belief that bad actors would liberalize if only they were integrated into the global system.

The organizing principle of America’s new approach is the existential  threat posed by the Chinese Communist Party. Under President Xi Jinping, China is executing a comprehensive grand strategy to supplant the US as the world’s leading power, and it is the only state capable of challenging US primacy militarily, economically, and technologically. Just as Europe needs America to respond to Russian aggression, America needs its allies in Europe to recognize the threat posed by China and to act accordingly if the free world is to maintain its advantages.

Despite the rhetoric, America and its Transatlantic allies still share, as King Charles III recently relayed to Congress, “common democratic, legal, and social traditions” and “vibrant, diverse and free societies that gives us our collective strength.” But as Europe pursues strategic autonomy to absorb the shock of an America now unapologetically placing national interest above globalism, they are in practice enacting an overt hedge away from America that serves China’s interests and undermines their own sovereignty.

While the European Union explicitly describes reducing dependence on China as part of its strategic autonomy ambitions, the actions of its member states are undermining this objective. The EU ran a €359.8 billion goods trade deficit with China in 2025, as imports rose 6.4% even as European leaders emphasized diversification. Moreover, widespread de-industrialization driven by Chinese manufacturing overcapacity and high energy costs is leading to devastating job loss, including approximately 10,000 manufacturing jobs per month disappearing in Germany. Over the past decade, EU imports from China have surged nearly 90%, further entrenching economic dependence on the one-party regime. Beijing’s grip on critical minerals, which supplies 97% of the EU’s magnesium and dominates the processing of rare earths essential to European defense and advanced technologies, also provides China a chokehold on the very technologies Europeans claim they want to control independently.

Predatory economic practices are occurring concomitantly with disinformation and elite cultivation. China has laundered state media content disguised as local journalism in Poland and the Czech Republic, employed AI-amplified calls for government overthrow in Spain, engaged in relentless “United Front” (the single Party’s term for the program)  cultivation of elites in Germany, the UK, and Italy, and much more to undermine their democracies.

 

Read also:
Can a mouse roar? Europe, China and strategic autonomy
Autonomia Strategica europea: nuovo paradigma o vicolo cieco?

 

To protect the Transatlantic alliance that is so critical to containing, deterring, and ultimately defeating both Russia and China if necessary, France, Germany, the UK, and other European powers must forgo their attempts to develop a “third way” in international affairs, a high-minded approach that has in practice only led to “diplomatic irrelevance, economic vulnerability and political marginalization.”

The fundamental problem with this third way is that the international system only has two superpowers, and European security and prosperity are overwhelmingly tied to one of them. Thus, any effort to reduce dependency on the superpowers naturally disproportionately impacts the US, creating space that only China possess the scale to fill. By increasing European economic dependency, Beijing increases its leverage and thus threatens weakening the Transatlantic alliance that complicates its revisionist and authoritarian global ambitions.

European powers should instead recognize that hedging against the United States only leads to greater dependency on China. To reverse course, Europe must take four key steps.

First, increased defense spending and improved allied burden sharing must accelerate, and should be viewed as reinforcing the alliance rather than eroding it. Second, these powers should recognize that assertive American action like Operations Absolute Resolve and Epic Fury are not wanton violations of international law, but rather America enforcing international law against its most flagrant violators. If they do not offer support, they should at least not get in the way. Third, they should selectively decouple from China on critical technologies and supply chains while joining the US in applying coordinated pressure on Beijing. And lastly, leaders must be honest with their populations, many of whom now view America as a greater threat than China, about the real threat posed by external actors. It is China and Russia, not the US, that represent a threat to European sovereignty, freedom, and economic prosperity.

A hedge away from the superpowers has meant in practice a hedge away from the United States and towards China, a country that will exploit this shift to advance its autocratic standards and collapse the American-led West.  A renewed Transatlantic bargain where US leadership is paired with fairer burden-sharing, selective decoupling from China in critical technologies and supply chains, moral clarity on the threat China poses, and joint pressure on Beijing offers middle powers real autonomy within the framework of US partnership.

 

 


A version of this article will appear in Italian in Aspenia 4/2026, due out at the end of the year.